The Real Reason Most Investors Underperform Their Investments

 

Here’s a stat that surprises almost everyone: most investors underperform the very investments they own.

 

The reason isn’t bad markets or bad products — it’s bad timing.


People buy high and sell low. That’s the opposite of the right way to do it.

 

When markets are up, confidence goes up — people add money.

When markets are down, fear takes over and they pull money out. Rinse and repeat.

 

It’s not an intelligence issue; it’s an emotion issue. It’s almost like we are programmed to lose.  The data proves it. DALBAR studies show investors consistently lag the funds they invest in by several percentage points per year, simply because of when they increase or decrease risk.

 

This is a common one for me:

Client - “Brandon, I was thinking about taking a little risk out here, because of ______.”

Me- “Oh you want to time the market?”

 

Then that same client wants to increase the risk or buy some aggressive stocks when things are going well.

If asked, they would tell you they are not timing the market, but that is what is going on here and why some investors underperform the investments they own.

 

If you can separate how you feel about the market from what you do in the market, you’re already ahead of most people.


Discipline always beats emotion.


The market rewards patience, not panic.

 
 
Brandon M. Cox, CFP®

Brandon founded Coastline Complete Wealth in June 2023 with a clear purpose: to serve clients better, embrace his role as a fiduciary, and remove conflicts of interest. Since beginning his career in 2010, much of it at a large national firm, he repeatedly asked himself one question—how can this be done better? CCW is the answer to that pursuit. The firm transitioned to a fully independent, SEC-registered investment adviser in December 2025.

Brandon has been recognized by Forbes as a Best-in-State Wealth Advisor* in South Carolina. He is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® professional and a Certified Financial Fiduciary®. He is also a member of the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (NAPFA) and the Fee-Only Network. Brandon is also the author of Lowcountry Retirement: A Fiduciary’s Perspective on Retirement Income, Taxes, and Financial Planning.

Learn more about Brandon.

Previous
Previous

Why Simplicity Wins in Wealth Management (And Complexity Sells)

Next
Next

Stop Chasing Headlines — The Market Doesn’t Care About the News